10 Signs Your Strategic Planning Is Failing You
Is your strategic planning failing you? These 10 signs, from one-day retreats to plans that never stop anything, show where the process breaks down.
4 min read
Cecilia Lynch
:
February 14, 2017 at 7:06 PM
A strategic vision describes the future you want your organization to create, vividly enough that people want to help build it. Most visions fall flat for one of two reasons: they are a bundle of current goals with no aspiration behind them, or a bold slogan with no story of how to get there. A strong vision avoids both by defining your ideal position, your impact, the business model you will need and how you will measure success.
Your vision is the destination in the vision step of strategic planning. Here is what it should include, why so many visions come up lame, and how to create one that powers your plan.
A vision describes, at a high level, the end state you hope to create. It should be robust, aspirational and a bit scary. It may even make you feel a little sheepish to say out loud, because it expresses your deepest ambitions for the organization. It should stretch you, but not to the point that the stretch snaps.
Visions can include many elements and still be powerful. At a minimum, we recommend these four:
Even a strong vision can outgrow an organization's current capacity. When a new department chair was selected to lead an academic physician group of more than 620 physicians for his transformational vision, a 45-person Strategy Creation session revealed that the department's vision and its members' aspirations were aligned, but its operating model and budget were not. Read the client story: The Weight of the Vision
Download our FREE Epic Strategy eBook and see how a compelling vision anchors a strategy people want to follow.
A vision should be one of the most powerful tools in a leader's strategic management toolkit. Too often it is not. Two causes come up again and again.
This vision is built by bundling the goals an organization hopes to accomplish over the coming months or years into one big package, in the hope that it will excite people like the biggest present under the tree. When it fails to inspire, leaders conclude that a vision cannot provide any real advantage.
The missing ingredient is aspiration. A vision is a picture of a future that is special and new. Without a higher purpose or a compelling impact, a sum-of-all-parts vision just looks like more work. Bigger, on its own, is not enough.
The second type is an overly simplified, far-reaching goal: a Big Hairy Audacious Goal, or BHAG. The concept comes from Jim Collins and Jerry Porras's research for Built to Last (see Jim Collins's description of the BHAG). It is not a visioning method. It works best as a rallying cry that distills a vision you have already crafted.
When a BHAG is used as a shortcut around the hard work of strategy development, it can ignite a desire to achieve the unachievable without a story of how to get there. The unveiling raises more questions than leaders can answer, and everyone ends up frustrated.
One industry leader experienced exactly this. Its CEO set a bold growth goal but left each department head to work out how to reach it. Two years later, the company was over budget and behind its deadlines, and its leaders were asking, "What is the plan?" A nine-month Strategy Summit® engagement replaced the competing departmental plans with one company-wide direction. Read the client story: Which Comes First?
In both cases, the problem is the same. A holistic, motivating vision takes time and a different mindset than the challenges leaders manage every day.
For some leaders, envisioning the future comes naturally. For the more pragmatic, defining a future destination can feel daunting. These steps work for both.
Your vision should look five to ten years out, while your strategic direction covers the next three to five years. Choose a horizon far enough out that you cannot be certain how you will get there, but not so far that a dangerous gap opens between that future and who you are today. Your vision still has to connect to what you do now.
Turn off your analytical mind and set aside language about what is and is not possible. Every great vision starts as a fragile, young idea that needs protection in its early stages.
Spend time with your idealistic self. These three prompts help prime a vision:
A milestone can be the perfect moment. As a significant cultural institution approached its 100th year, its board and staff recognized they needed a compelling vision of the future before they could plan a celebration of the past. The vision created in those planning sessions guided the design of a new campus and a capital campaign, and its core continues to guide the organization today. Read the client story: 100 Years Young
If your organization was built on a strong founding vision, it can be the starter for every new strategic plan. San Francisco's Boudin Bakery says each loaf of its sourdough is still made with a portion of the original mother dough that dates back to its first loaf in 1849 (Boudin Bakery). A founding vision can work the same way. Bakers take a small amount of the mother dough each day to start the day's bread; leadership teams can take the essence of the founding vision to start each planning cycle, and feed it so it grows into a strong culture and a lasting advantage.
The caveat is that the founding vision must still be relevant. Many organizations reinvent themselves as times change. But if the founding vision is values-based, describing the impact the founders wanted to have or the kind of organization they wanted to build, it can still be the starter.
Tip: A history-gram, a visual timeline of your organization's evolution, is a great way to honor the past and bring newer team members up to speed with longer-tenured ones at the start of planning. It can unite a tentative team quickly, so everyone is more comfortable speaking up with their best thinking.
Your vision is the destination. To see how it fits with your assessment and strategic direction, read what are the steps in strategic planning.
Download our Consulting Services Guide to see how we work and which engagement fits your situation.
Is your strategic planning failing you? These 10 signs, from one-day retreats to plans that never stop anything, show where the process breaks down.
What are the steps in strategic planning? Three phases: a strategic assessment, strategy creation, and plan development and integration into one plan.
Learn why strategic planning consulting engagements fail and how to protect your next investment with execution-focused planning that lasts.