3 min read

10 Signs Your Strategic Planning Is Failing You

10 Signs Your Strategic Planning Is Failing You

The clearest signs your strategic planning is failing show up in how you plan, long before results slip. If your process is a single annual meeting, avoids hard choices, or leaves each department to work out the plan on its own, the plan is likely to stall no matter how good it looks on paper.

Look for these ten signs in three areas: your process, your thinking and your follow-through. How many sound familiar?

Signs in Your Planning Process

1. Your strategic planning is a one-day annual meeting.

A day away from the office is a good start, but it is not a plan. Strategy needs time for assessment before the session and for plan development after it. When the meeting is the whole process, the new thinking rarely survives the return to daily work.

2. You generate lots of ideas but leave the "how" for later.

Ideas without owners, timelines and resources stay ideas. In most organizations, "later" means never.

3. Your plans never come together into one multi-year plan.

Each initiative gets its own plan, but no one stages and sequences them into a single plan the organization can actually carry out.



Is your plan set up to fail?

 

Download our FREE eBook, Epic Strategy Failure, to learn three common causes and how to combat them.


Signs in Your Strategic Thinking

4. Growth is discussed only as year-over-year gains.

When the conversation turns to the future and someone quantifies it as unit growth or price increases, the team has slipped into annual business planning. That discussion belongs in budgeting, not in strategy.

One market leader learned this when competitors began squeezing it from above and below. Its core performance metric, year-over-year net operating income, was anchored to a market that no longer existed. Before it could build a response, its leadership team had to rethink how it defined success. Read the client story: The Big Squeeze

5. Competitors and the market are missing from the conversation.

If no one can say where your goals came from, they are probably grounded in assumptions rather than market intelligence. Time spent understanding your competitors and where your market is heading should shape the plan, not sit in an appendix.

A nonprofit's new leadership team found that the plan it inherited had been built from the inside looking out, and they expected to revise its core assumptions within the first year. Mapping the three market sectors the organization served changed the plan's direction and helped it secure significant funding for a new entity. Read the client story: Lost in the Dark

6. You never decide what to stop.

You know new priorities require trade-offs, but nothing ever comes off the list. Strategic planning should reveal what your organization no longer needs to do, or should no longer keep doing. Boards almost always ask this question. If no one asks you, ask yourselves.

Signs in Your Follow-Through

7. Each department fits the new direction into its own plans.

The new direction is announced, and each department heads off to work it into next year's plans and budgets. Later, no one can say how the budgets tie back to the strategy.

An academic physician group of more than 600 physicians across 17 specialty divisions had an approved plan and a structure built to support it, yet implementation had not taken hold. Facilitated alignment planning with each functional and administrative team turned strategic roles into concrete, resourced implementation plans. Three years in, the plan was still guiding decisions. Read the client story: Everyone in Their Lane

8. Your goals raise more questions than answers at budget time.

Teams review the strategic goals as budgeting begins, cannot explain them, and move on. The goals then wait until someone specifically asks about them. That is a sign the goals were never connected to the work.

9. Cross-functional planning drifts back to old problems.

The work starts strong, but within a month the group is solving the same problems it always solves.

10. You are always one step behind.

You work hard to meet customer demands, and by the time you deliver, customers have moved on to new ones. You invest in change, and by launch the market has moved again. A plan that only reacts will always be chasing.

Why Better Execution Will Not Fix It

When results fall short, leaders often blame execution. They invest in software that links strategic goals to operating plans, or assign an experienced project manager to drive implementation. Those are good investments, but they cannot rescue the wrong goals.

Sustained performance comes from setting the right goals and deliberately fostering the new thinking needed to reach them. That takes a complete process: strategic assessment, strategy creation, and plan development and integration. A planning meeting is where strategy starts, not where it is finished. That is why strategic planning is so hard to lead: each of these signs points to a step that was skipped or rushed.

If several signs sound familiar, check your process against the critical elements your strategic planning may be missing.



Recognize your organization in these signs?

 

Download our Consulting Services Guide to see how we work and which engagement fits your situation.


6 Critical Elements Your Strategic Planning May Be Missing

6 Critical Elements Your Strategic Planning May Be Missing

Six critical elements strategic planning often misses, from an outside-in view to the integration step that turns ideas into a plan you can carry out.

Read full post
Transform Your Strategic Planning Process: 3 Essential Steps

Transform Your Strategic Planning Process: 3 Essential Steps

Learn to transform your strategic planning process through disruption. Discover the 3 key phases that ignite strategic thinking for breakthrough...

Read full post
What Are the Steps in Strategic Planning? 3 Phases Explained

What Are the Steps in Strategic Planning? 3 Phases Explained

What are the steps in strategic planning? Three phases: a strategic assessment, strategy creation, and plan development and integration into one plan.

Read full post